Why I Stopped Coaching Tennis by the Book…..and What Happened Next

Steve reflects on their coaching evolution, realizing that traditional methods fail to prepare players for competition. Emphasizing adaptability, they adopt Ecological Dynamics and Constraint-Led Coaching, focusing on decision-making and problem-solving. The approach shifts from perfect technique to cultivating players who thrive during matches, leading to better outcomes and more responsive athletes.

For years, I did everything “right.”

I planned every session meticulously.
I used basket drills.
I structured my lessons with textbook progressions.
I taught the perfect forehand.

And yet, when it came time to compete, my players crumbled.

They couldn’t problem-solve.
They couldn’t adapt.
They froze under pressure.

That’s when I realized something most coaching courses don’t prepare you for:

Textbook tennis coaching doesn’t transfer to the match court.

The Problem with Traditional Tennis Coaching

Like many coaches, I was simply teaching the way I had been taught.
Repetition.
Biomechanical checkpoints.
Perfect feeding.

Thousands of hours. Thousands of fed balls. And yet, the outcomes didn’t match the effort.

When the game got real—when it came to playing points, my players didn’t have the tools to adapt, solve problems, or make decisions under pressure.
They were trained to replicate, not to respond.

That’s when I started questioning everything.


From Basket Feeds to Behavioral Change

Over the past six years, I’ve shifted my entire approach. I stopped chasing perfect technique and started building adaptable players.

The foundation?
Ecological Dynamics.

Instead of prescribing strokes, I now create environments where players interact with the game. They learn through doing, not by copying. The drills are gone. What’s replaced them is something far more powerful:

  • Constraints that shape intention and behavior
  • Scenarios that demand decision-making
  • Tasks that reveal real solutions, not scripted ones

Take a recent example: I’ve been working with an under-9 player who, until recently, was taught the traditional way, static drills, explicit instruction, and a “correct” way to move.

In a few short months, that’s all changed.

He now serves with intention, not by following a model, but by discovering how to jam or stretch his opponent through task design. His ability to adapt and compete has skyrocketed.

And the best part?

He’s doing it without being told how to move.


Coaching That Reflects the Game

This isn’t a set of drills.
It’s not a new technique.
It’s a coaching mindset, one that sees tennis as a complex, dynamic, and constantly changing interaction between player, opponent, and environment.

And once I embraced that?

Everything changed.

I became less concerned with producing textbook strokes and more focused on cultivating match-ready players. Players who:

  • Make decisions on their own
  • Respond to pressure
  • Create solutions….not copy them

Why I Built My Tennis Coaching

I know I’m not alone.

If you’re a coach who plans every session, keeps up with your CPD, and still feels like something isn’t clicking, I’ve been there.

You don’t need more stress. You don’t need to start from scratch.

You need a framework that works with the player, not on them.

That’s why I built My Tennis Coaching, a platform, a community, and a philosophy that shares the principles and practices behind Ecological Dynamics and Constraint-Led Coaching.

I share weekly insights, real-life examples, and practice designs that work in the chaos of the match—not just the comfort of a drill.

If that’s the kind of coaching you want to explore, I invite you to join my free newsletter and follow along.


Final Thought

This isn’t about bashing tradition.
Traditional methods got us this far. But tennis isn’t scripted, and neither should our sessions be.

So ask yourself:

Are the methods you used 10 years ago still the most effective way to coach today?

If not, you’re not alone. And you’re not without support.

Let’s coach for the game, not the textbook.

Join the Coaching Evolution

Practical tools, fresh ideas, and real solutions for busy tennis coaches who want to do less, and coach better

    READ THESE NEXT

    Join the Coaching Evolution

    Practical tools, fresh ideas, and real solutions for busy tennis coaches who want to do less and coach better

    Join The Coaches Playbook Newsletter Today

      We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.

      JOIN THE COACHING EVOLUTION

      Practical tools, fresh ideas, and real solutions for busy tennis coaches who want to do less, and coach better

        About the Author

        Written by Steve Whelan

        Steve Whelan is a tennis coach, coach educator, and researcher with 24+ years of on-court experience working across grassroots, performance, and coach development environments. His work focuses on how players actually learn, specialising in practice design, skill transfer, and ecological dynamics in tennis.

        Steve has presented at national and international coaching conferences, contributed to coach education programmes, and published work exploring intention, attention, affordances, and representative learning design in tennis. His writing bridges academic research and real-world coaching, helping coaches move beyond drills toward practices that hold up under match pressure.

        He is the founder of My Tennis Coaching and My Tennis Coach Academy, a global learning community for coaches seeking modern, evidence-informed approaches to player development.

        👉 Learn more about Steve’s coaching journey and philosophy here:
        About / My Journey

        Leave a Reply

        Discover more from My Tennis Coaching

        Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

        Continue reading