My Reflections: When Does Technique become ‘permanent’ ?

Blog banner featuring Tennis Coach Educator Steve Whelan, titled 'My Coaching Reflections', for a series on MyTennisCoaching.com.
The nature of movement in tennis is ever-evolving. It's unrealistic to expect permanent technique, considering the unpredictability of a player's development. "Temporary movement solutions" tailored to the present moment are advocated, as seen in an example of an 8-year-old's jump serve. The emphasis should shift from rigid shapes to adopting immediate game-specific solutions.

In a recent conversation with a fellow coach, the topic of technique’s permanence surfaced. We pondered, after how many repetitions does a forehand become second nature to a player? This question led me to consider the nature of movement in tennis. Observing the evolution of Novak Djokovic’s serve or Andy Murray’s adaptations post-hip surgery, it’s evident that technique is continually evolving.

Is it realistic, then, to expect a player to reach a point where their technique becomes immutable? I’m sceptical. With the young athletes I mentor, my focus is on providing solutions that work for today. Projecting too far into the future seems futile, given the unpredictability of a player’s development across physical, emotional, and potential injury-related changes.

This mindset has led me to advocate for what I term “temporary movement solutions.” These are ways players can utilize their racket, footwork, or body mechanics to succeed or overcome a challenge in the present moment. A recent example from a training session involved an 8-year-old practising a jump serve to gain more power, as instructed by his coach. Given his lack of leg strength, the ineffectiveness of this technique with a sponge ball and on a smaller court, and the unnecessary strain on his kinetic chain, it was clear this advice was misaligned with his current capabilities. This scenario illustrates the risk of coaching with a professional game mindset, rather than tailoring guidance to the individual player before you.

Rob Gray’s “How We Learn To Move” highlights a study on the variability of knee bend in professional tennis players, demonstrating the diverse and adaptive nature of their movements even within a single match. This reinforces my belief that technique and movement should not be viewed as permanent fixtures.

The myth of muscle memory and the emphasis on high repetition have long been propagated in tennis coaching circles. However, perhaps it’s time to shift our focus away from prescribing rigid “shapes” or basic movement patterns. Instead, we should encourage players to explore and adopt temporary solutions that address the immediate demands of the game they’re engaged in.

Book a my mentoring call

Fast Track Your Coach Development with A Personal Call

Take the next step in your coaching

Explore practical examples, expert sessions and a community of coaches who want to understand learning, not simply collect more drills.

Explore Academy membership

Not ready to join? Start with the free Practice-to-Match Scorecard or The Coaching Playbook newsletter.

For clubs, federations and coach education teams: discuss a workshop or consultancy project.

Join the Coaching Evolution

Practical tools, fresh ideas, and real solutions for busy tennis coaches who want to do less, and coach better

    READ THESE NEXT

    Join the Coaching Evolution

    Practical tools, fresh ideas, and real solutions for busy tennis coaches who want to do less and coach better

    ​

    Join The Coaches Playbook Newsletter Today

      We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.

      JOIN THE COACHING EVOLUTION

      Practical tools, fresh ideas, and real solutions for busy tennis coaches who want to do less, and coach better

        About the Author

        Written by Steve Whelan

        Steve Whelan is a tennis coach developer, coach educator and founder of My Tennis Coaching. He has coached since 1999 across grassroots, performance and coach development environments, and is completing an MRes focused on coaching and coach development.

        His work draws on ecological dynamics, the Constraints-Led Approach and representative learning design. He writes about practice design, skill acquisition and how coaches learn and change.

        Read Steve’s biography, qualifications and published work · LTA coach profile · ORCID research profile

        Leave a Reply