For the first 18 years of my tennis coaching career, one of my biggest frustrations was watching players perform incredibly well in practice, only to see that performance disappear when they started playing matches.
I would spend 30 or 40 minutes developing a player’s technique. We would work on their contact point, racket preparation, balance, footwork and swing path.
By the end of the practice, the player looked great.
Then we played points.
Suddenly, the technique we had spent so much time developing seemed to disappear.
When I spoke to other coaches and mentors about this, the responses were generally quite similar.
They need more repetitions.
They’re not mentally strong enough.
They’re not concentrating.
They’re not trying hard enough.
As a young tennis coach, I found this incredibly frustrating. I was following the methods I had been taught on coach education courses. I was doing what I had seen hundreds of other tennis coaches doing.
Yet something wasn’t quite working.
It took me many years to start asking a different question.
What if the problem wasn’t necessarily the player? What if it was the practice?
What is skill transfer in tennis coaching?
Skill transfer refers to the extent to which learning developed in one situation can be applied in another.
For tennis coaches, the most important example is whether the capabilities players develop on the practice court help them perform on the match court.
However, improving performance during a practice doesn’t necessarily mean learning has taken place.
A player hitting 50 consistent forehands from a basket feed has demonstrated that they can perform that particular task. Whether they can recognise an opportunity to use their forehand, adapt their movement and execute an effective shot against an unpredictable opponent is a different question.
This distinction between performance and learning is well established within skill-acquisition research.
A 2015 review by Soderstrom and Bjork highlighted how improvements during practice can be unreliable indicators of longer-term learning, retention and transfer.
Essentially, just because a player is getting better at a practice doesn’t necessarily mean they are getting better at tennis.
That distinction has dramatically changed how I coach.
What information are we removing from tennis practice?
When I reflect on my traditional coaching methods, one of the biggest issues was how much information I removed from the practice environment.
I would stand with a basket, feeding balls from a relatively consistent position.
Sometimes I would introduce variability. I might feed a higher ball, a lower ball, a faster ball or a ball with different spin.
But I was still removing one of the most important elements of competitive tennis.
The opponent.
Tennis is a dynamic, interactive game. What one player does influences what the other player can do.
The opponent’s position, movement, racket action and the trajectory of the incoming ball all provide information that can help a player regulate their behaviour.
The player’s own shot then changes the situation again.
If I stretch my opponent out wide, I potentially create a different opportunity for my next shot. If I hit a short ball, I might allow my opponent to move forward and take time away from me.
Every action changes the environment in which the next action takes place.
In many of my previous coaching practices, those relationships didn’t exist.
My player would hit a forehand, and I would immediately feed another ball.
It didn’t really matter where their previous forehand went. It didn’t affect where the next ball came from. There was no opponent responding to their actions.
I was introducing variability in the feed, but I wasn’t necessarily preserving the interactions that make tennis such a variable game.
From an ecological dynamics perspective, this presents a potential problem for skill transfer because the information that regulates movement in practice can differ substantially from the information available in competition.
Do players need to learn the basic technique first?
One of the most common arguments I hear is that players need to develop a reliable basic technique before they can start playing the game.
It’s an argument I used myself for many years.
I spent hundreds, probably thousands, of hours helping players develop what I understood to be fundamental tennis techniques.
I invested considerable time in developing my knowledge of biomechanics and understanding how different tennis strokes worked.
Yet I still experienced the same problem.
Players who could demonstrate technically proficient strokes in controlled environments often struggled to adapt those strokes when playing points.
I’m not suggesting that technique doesn’t matter. Of course it matters.
What I increasingly question is the assumption that technique must be developed separately from the problems it is intended to solve.
I’ve yet to encounter compelling evidence that establishes an isolated technique-first progression as a necessary prerequisite for learning to play tennis.
A functional forehand isn’t simply a movement that looks technically correct.
It needs to help the player achieve something.
Can the player adapt to different ball heights?
Can they take time away from an opponent?
Can they create an angle?
Can they survive when they are stretched?
Can they adjust their movement when the situation changes unexpectedly?
These are technical challenges, but they are also perceptual and tactical challenges.
Separating them may make the coach’s job appear simpler, but it doesn’t necessarily make the player’s learning more effective.
Simplify the game rather than remove the game
One of the biggest misconceptions about representative practice is that it means throwing a beginner into a complex match environment and expecting them to work everything out.
That’s not what I advocate.
Imagine I’m working with a six-year-old beginner who struggles to make contact with the ball.
There are potentially several challenges facing that player. They are developing their sensitivity to the movement of the ball, learning where they need to position themselves and exploring how to coordinate their body and racket effectively.
They also face what motor-control researchers describe as the degrees-of-freedom problem: learning to coordinate the many movement possibilities available to them.
Previously, I would probably have broken this down into separate technical elements.
Today, I’m more interested in how I can simplify the task while preserving meaningful opportunities for the player to explore these relationships.
I might use a smaller court, a slower ball, a lower net or allow the player additional touches.
Practical example: Two-touch tennis
Two-touch tennis is a practice I regularly use with beginners.
Rather than asking the player to return the incoming ball immediately, I allow them an initial controlling touch with the racket before using a second touch to send the ball towards their opponent.
The first touch provides the player with information.
How does changing the racket-face angle affect the ball?
What happens if they make contact too far away from their body?
What happens if they contact the ball late?
Can they control the ball in a way that makes the second touch easier?
Rather than me continually telling the player how to position their racket, the consequences of their actions can help them explore more functional solutions.
I can still guide their attention through questions, demonstrations or carefully chosen instructions.
Importantly, I can preserve an opponent, a barrier, an intention and a scoring system.
Even with three- and four-year-old players, we can explore similar problems by rolling balls along the floor, with a line acting as a barrier.
I’m not expecting a four-year-old to play Wimbledon.
I’m trying to help them develop a relationship with the essential problems of the game at a level that is accessible to them.
Start with the intention of tennis
At its most basic level, one of the central objectives of tennis is to put the ball into a position where your opponent struggles to return it, while preventing them from doing the same to you.
This principle guides much of my coaching today.
Within the My Tennis Coaching Academy, we have developed a simple framework to help coaches observe and understand player intentions:
- Stretch: Can you move your opponent into a position where they struggle to make an effective return?
- Jam: Can you restrict your opponent’s available space or time?
- Survive: Can you find a way to return the ball when you are under pressure, stretched or jammed?
There are numerous technical, tactical and movement solutions available within these intentions.
A player might stretch an opponent through angle, depth, height, speed or changes in spin.
They might jam an opponent through a fast ball towards their body, a deep ball that restricts their contact space or a shot that takes time away from them.
The important thing is that the movement solution has a purpose.
When I observe players now, I’m interested in how they win and lose points.
What opportunities are they recognising?
What opportunities are they overlooking?
How do their actions affect their opponent?
How do they adapt when their opponent changes their behaviour?
This applies whether I’m working with a beginner or a performance player.
Performance skills aren’t exclusively for performance academies. Anyone learning to play tennis can benefit from developing the ability to solve the problems of the game.
Stop working forwards from practice. Start working backwards from competition.
Perhaps the biggest change in my coaching over the past few years has been where I start.
Previously, I would develop a series of technical and tactical tools on the practice court, hoping that my players would eventually use those tools successfully in competition.
Today, I increasingly work the other way around.
I watch my players compete.
I observe how they win points.
I observe how they lose points.
I look at the situations in which they appear comfortable and the situations in which they struggle.
I then bring that information back onto the practice court and design environments that encourage them to explore those problems or enhance behaviours that are already effective.
This doesn’t mean that every coaching intervention needs to address a weakness.
Sometimes the most valuable thing I can do is help a player recognise and exploit the strengths they already possess.
Instead of trying to develop an imagined future version of the player, I’m working with the player and the behaviours that currently exist.
If you cannot regularly watch players in tournaments, you can still begin your sessions with competitive points.
Observe before you intervene.
What is the actual problem?
Is it the same problem you thought you were going to address before the session started?
This is something I explored in my article on What Makes a Good Tennis Coach?
Increasingly, I don’t want to coach what I know.
I want to coach what I see.
Can tennis practice actually develop the wrong behaviours?
One of the challenges I currently face with some of my red-stage academy players is that they consistently hit the ball directly towards their opponent.
Even when there is plenty of space available elsewhere on the court, they frequently send the ball straight back to the other player.
I know that many of these players have previously experienced cooperative coaching practices, often on half courts, where the objective was to maintain a rally.
One possible explanation is that they have become highly attuned to opportunities to send the ball towards a partner rather than away from an opponent.
However, there are other possible explanations.
They might be worried about making mistakes.
They might struggle to control the direction of the ball.
They might find the movement demands of a full red court challenging.
I cannot simply assume that their previous coaching is the sole cause of the behaviour.
What interests me, though, is the possibility that some of the behaviour developed in previous practice has transferred successfully, but it isn’t necessarily helping the players win competitive points.
This is where coaches need to consider the possibility of negative transfer.
Sometimes the problem isn’t that nothing has transferred.
Sometimes it’s that we’ve developed a behaviour that serves the wrong purpose.
Practical example: The two-bounce game
One simple practice I use with these players involves placing a cone or throw-down marker beside the net post.
The objective is to move the marker onto your side of the court.
To earn the marker, you need to make the ball bounce twice on your opponent’s side. The first bounce must land inside the singles court, but the second bounce can be anywhere.
If your opponent achieves two bounces, the marker moves to their side.
This creates two problems simultaneously.
How can I send the ball somewhere that makes it difficult for my opponent to reach before the second bounce?
And how can I prevent my opponent from doing the same to me?
Suddenly, the space away from the opponent becomes much more relevant to the player.
The practice can encourage exploration of angles, depth, changes of speed and different movement solutions without me prescribing exactly which shot the player must hit.
But I still need to return to normal match play.
Does the player continue to recognise opportunities to exploit space when the additional scoring constraint is removed?
Do they adapt against different opponents?
Does the behaviour continue to emerge in subsequent sessions?
That is where I begin to assess whether the practice has been useful beyond the activity itself.
What does the research say about representative tennis practice?
Representative Learning Design is a framework that encourages coaches to preserve important information and action opportunities from the performance environment when designing practice.
It doesn’t mean every practice needs to look exactly like a match.
It means we need to understand which aspects of competition are relevant to the capabilities we are trying to develop.
There is some particularly interesting tennis-specific research in this area.
In 2019, Krause and colleagues examined four commonly used tennis practice tasks and compared player behaviour within these activities with behaviour during match play.
They identified differences between practice and competition, including more cooperative behaviour and longer rallies during practice.
This is important because it demonstrates that different practice environments can encourage different behaviours, even when the activities superficially resemble the same sport.
However, identifying these differences doesn’t automatically tell us which practice produces the greatest long-term learning.
In another 2019 study, Krause and colleagues investigated skill transfer in tennis serving across a six-week training intervention.
They compared three practice conditions:
- Serving without an opponent.
- Serving against a returner.
- Serving against a returner and playing an additional shot.
Interestingly, increasing the representativeness of practice did not produce a straightforward linear increase in skill acquisition.
Different practice conditions encouraged different adaptations. For example, the more representative practice group placed greater emphasis on second-serve placement relative to speed during match play.
For me, this is an important finding.
It doesn’t justify saying that every representative practice is better than every isolated practice.
What it does suggest is that coaches need to think carefully about what their practices are developing and whether those adaptations are appropriate for the individual player.
If you’re interested in assessing your own practices, I’ve also developed a Tennis Practice Assessment Scorecardinspired by research into Representative Learning Design.
Is there still a place for isolated and cooperative tennis practice?
Yes, but I think coaches need to be considerably clearer about why they are using them.
I don’t see anything inherently wrong with using a couple of basket feeds or drop feeds to help guide a player’s attention towards something they haven’t previously noticed.
An isolated practice might help me communicate a particular intention, highlight a relationship between racket angle and ball flight, or temporarily reduce the difficulty of a task.
Cooperative practice can also serve useful purposes.
The challenge comes when we assume that improvement within these activities will automatically produce adaptable, competitive tennis behaviours.
A player might become extremely competent at maintaining a cooperative rally.
But maintaining a rally and trying to prevent your opponent from returning the ball are different intentions.
They can encourage different behaviours.
Rather than categorising practices as good or bad, I would encourage coaches to ask:
What is this practice developing?
What information is available to the player?
What information have I removed?
What behaviours might the practice encourage?
And how will I establish whether those behaviours are useful in competition?
The purpose of a practice matters more than the label we give it.
The illusion of learning in tennis coaching
One of the biggest barriers to introducing more representative practices is, in my opinion, the discomfort experienced by coaches.
Players might miss more shots.
They might hit fewer balls.
Their technique might look less conventional.
The session might appear less organised.
But have you watched a tennis match recently?
Tennis players make mistakes.
They constantly adapt their movements to different ball heights, speeds, spins, positions, opponents and environmental conditions.
Even at the highest levels of the game, players rarely experience exactly the same situation twice.
Competitive tennis also frequently involves relatively short points, although rally lengths vary considerably according to playing level, court surface and other factors.
Yet many tennis coaching environments prioritise extended rallies and large numbers of continuous repetitions.
Sometimes we create an illusion of learning because the practice looks neat, tidy and technically impressive.
But are we developing the behaviours players need to compete?
This doesn’t mean that more mistakes automatically produce more learning. Nor does it mean that the coach should create environments so difficult that players cannot experience meaningful success.
The challenge is to find a level of difficulty that allows players to explore, adapt and experience the consequences of their actions.
I would rather observe whether a player becomes more adaptable over several weeks, against different opponents and under different scoring conditions, than simply count how many balls they hit during a one-hour lesson.
Ultimately, my practice environment isn’t there to make me feel comfortable as a coach.
It’s there to prepare the player for the demands of tennis.
Three simple ways to improve skill transfer in your next tennis lesson
You don’t need to completely reinvent yourself as a tennis coach.
If you want to start exploring how your practices could better prepare players for matches, I would encourage you to consider three relatively simple changes.
1. Include an opponent
Wherever possible, include an opponent within the practice.
If you’re working on the serve, introduce a returner.
If you’re working on the forehand, allow the player to explore where and when to use it against an opponent who can respond.
The opponent doesn’t necessarily need to make the practice extremely difficult. You can manipulate their starting position, movement opportunities or available options.
The important thing is that their presence and actions provide meaningful information to the player.
Simply having somebody standing on the other side of the net isn’t necessarily enough.
Give their presence a purpose.
2. Include consequences
Introduce a scoring or value-based system.
The score is an important constraint within competitive tennis.
A player serving at 40–0 might behave very differently when serving at 0–40.
Some players become more conservative under pressure. Others become more aggressive. Some may barely change their approach at all.
Without introducing these situations, it can be difficult to observe how individual players respond.
Purposeful scoring systems can also encourage players to explore different intentions and opportunities.
But be careful that players don’t simply become experts at exploiting your modified scoring system.
Return to conventional scoring and observe what happens.
3. Keep the shots connected
Wherever possible, preserve the relationship between the shot you’re developing, the shot that preceded it and the shot that follows it.
If you’re working on attacking a short ball, how did the short ball emerge?
What did the player do afterwards?
How did the opponent respond?
If you’re working on the serve, consider allowing the return and the subsequent shot.
If you’re working on defensive forehands, allow the player to experience how an opponent might create that defensive situation.
These relationships can be lost when we continually restart a practice after an isolated action.
Constraints can help you increase the likelihood of particular situations emerging without completely removing the interaction.
You can still work on specific aspects of the game.
You don’t necessarily need to remove the game to do it.
How do you know if your tennis coaching is transferring into matches?
For me, there are several questions worth returning to over time.
Can the player recognise opportunities without me pointing them out?
Can they adapt their movements to different situations?
Can they solve similar problems against different opponents?
Can they continue to perform when the practice constraints are removed?
Can they manage changes in the score?
Can they reproduce or adapt effective behaviours in subsequent sessions and competitions?
None of these questions can be answered simply by watching a player perform one drill.
Progress requires observation over time and across different environments.
And sometimes, despite our best intentions, we discover that a practice hasn’t developed the behaviour we expected it to.
That’s not necessarily a failure of the player.
It might be an opportunity for us to reconsider our coaching.
Are we developing better practice players or better tennis players?
For many years, I believed that my role as a tennis coach was to provide players with the technical tools they would eventually need to play the game.
Today, I see my role differently.
I want to help players become more sensitive to the information available within tennis.
I want to help them recognise opportunities, explore solutions and adapt their behaviours to the problems they encounter.
I want to help them become more capable of performing when I’m no longer standing beside them.
That doesn’t mean abandoning technical knowledge.
It doesn’t mean abandoning instruction.
And it certainly doesn’t mean abandoning the player and expecting them to work everything out for themselves.
It means being more thoughtful about the environments we create and the behaviours those environments encourage.
The next time your player looks fantastic in practice but struggles in a match, perhaps resist the temptation to immediately question their technique, concentration or mental strength.
Instead, ask yourself:
What have I been preparing this player to do?
Because ultimately, my objective as a tennis coach isn’t to develop players who are excellent at my practices.
It’s to help players become better at playing tennis.
Develop your understanding of tennis coaching
If you’re interested in exploring how ecological dynamics, the Constraints-Led Approach and contemporary skill-acquisition research can inform your everyday tennis coaching, the My Tennis Coaching Academy is designed to help you do exactly that.
Through practical coaching examples, webinars, coach development resources and conversations with other coaches, we explore not only what practices to use, but why we use them, what to observe and how we can help players develop more adaptable behaviours.
It’s not simply about collecting more tennis drills.
It’s about developing your understanding of coaching.
Explore the My Tennis Coaching Academy
Continue your learning: related coaching guides
Skill transfer is not one coaching intervention. It is a question we need to revisit across tasks, opponents and time. The following resources explore different aspects of that question, from movement adaptability to the evidence behind practice design.
- Why technique can fail to transfer to matches — Explore possible explanations for the practice–competition gap.
- Assessing representative practice — Use a scorecard to examine the practice environment.
- Consistency and movement adaptability — Explore why useful outcomes do not require identical movements.
- How tennis movement develops — Consider the information that guides positioning and movement.
- Learning stages and the evidence — Distinguish immediate practice performance, retention and transfer.
- What makes a good tennis coach? — Reflect on how observation and coaching judgement inform practice.
Browse the full tennis coaching article library for more topics.
References and further reading
- Krause, L., Farrow, D., Reid, M., Buszard, T., & Pinder, R. (2018). Helping coaches apply the principles of representative learning design: Validation of a tennis specific practice assessment tool. Journal of Sports Sciences, 36(11), 1277–1286. https://doi.org/10.1080/02640414.2017.1374684
- Krause, L., Farrow, D., Buszard, T., Pinder, R., & Reid, M. (2019). Application of representative learning design for assessment of common practice tasks in tennis. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 41, 36–45. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychsport.2018.11.008
- Krause, L., Farrow, D., Pinder, R., Buszard, T., Kovalchik, S., & Reid, M. (2019). Enhancing skill transfer in tennis using representative learning design. Journal of Sports Sciences, 37(22), 2560–2568. https://doi.org/10.1080/02640414.2019.1647739
- Soderstrom, N. C., & Bjork, R. A. (2015). Learning versus performance: An integrative review. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 10(2), 176–199. https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691615569000
Comments on How Can Tennis Coaches Help Players Transfer Practice Into Matches?