My Coaching Reflections: Fear of Failure in Tennis Coaching

Blog banner featuring Tennis Coach Educator Steve Whelan, titled 'My Coaching Reflections', for a series on MyTennisCoaching.com.
The author observes a lack of encouragement for creativity in tennis coaching, advocating for a shift in mindset. Emphasizing the contextual nature of decisions in tennis, the author urges coaches to foster a culture of reflection and learning from failures. This approach aims to develop independent, creative thinkers on the court. How do you encourage creativity in your coaching?


In our quest for more creative players in tennis, I’ve noticed a trend in coaching environments that either discourage creativity or present it as an illusion. It’s time we address this.

What really constitutes a ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ decision in tennis? From my experience, a decision that’s right in one context might be wrong in another. This highlights the need for players to make errors and learn from them. Let’s consider a tennis lesson scenario: a player goes for a difficult winner down the line from a wide, heavy ball. Conventional coaching wisdom might label this as a low-percentage, incorrect decision. But change the context slightly—a less wide ball, for example—and the same decision might be the smart move.

As coaches, we’re quick to offer our expertise, but we must remember we don’t experience the game as the player does. Tennis is dynamic, requiring high levels of problem-solving and creativity, yet often, we don’t foster this in our lessons. Instead, we step in immediately to correct mistakes, inadvertently fostering a fear of failure in our players. They start giving answers they think we want to hear, or we steer them towards the ‘right’ answer, further instilling this fear.

This fear of failure can manifest in matches as players play it safe, avoid risks, and miss opportunities. It’s a cycle we, as coaches, inadvertently contribute to. But it doesn’t have to be this way.

How do we break this cycle? Let’s start by encouraging our players to explore and experiment. When they make a decision, whether it leads to success or an error, let’s ask them to reflect on it. What alternatives did they see? What would they do differently next time? By encouraging this kind of reflective practice and embracing failure as a learning opportunity, we can help them develop a deeper understanding of the game.

Children don’t start playing tennis with a fear of losing; it’s a learned behaviour, often influenced by our coaching styles. Let’s change the narrative. Let’s encourage players to discuss their choices openly, reflect on the information they used, and understand the context of their decisions. This way, we’re not just coaching tennis players; we’re nurturing independent, creative thinkers on the court.

What are your thoughts on this approach? How do you encourage creativity and risk-taking in your coaching?

Take the next step in your coaching

Explore practical examples, expert sessions and a community of coaches who want to understand learning, not simply collect more drills.

Explore Academy membership

Not ready to join? Start with the free Practice-to-Match Scorecard or The Coaching Playbook newsletter.

For clubs, federations and coach education teams: discuss a workshop or consultancy project.

Join the Coaching Evolution

Practical tools, fresh ideas, and real solutions for busy tennis coaches who want to do less, and coach better

    READ THESE NEXT

    Join the Coaching Evolution

    Practical tools, fresh ideas, and real solutions for busy tennis coaches who want to do less and coach better

    ​

    Join The Coaches Playbook Newsletter Today

      We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.

      JOIN THE COACHING EVOLUTION

      Practical tools, fresh ideas, and real solutions for busy tennis coaches who want to do less, and coach better

        About the Author

        Written by Steve Whelan

        Steve Whelan is a tennis coach developer, coach educator and founder of My Tennis Coaching. He has coached since 1999 across grassroots, performance and coach development environments, and is completing an MRes focused on coaching and coach development.

        His work draws on ecological dynamics, the Constraints-Led Approach and representative learning design. He writes about practice design, skill acquisition and how coaches learn and change.

        Read Steve’s biography, qualifications and published work · LTA coach profile · ORCID research profile

        Leave a Reply